** Special to the Just Word Blog from Robin Powell, the UK based editor of The Evidence-Based Investor and consultant to investors, planners & advisors **
More than a century of market records shows what helped investors through frightening times: spreading their money widely, and holding a mix they could stick with.
“We are in the midst of a rupture, not a transition.” When Prime Minister Mark Carney delivered that warning at Davos, he was describing the breakdown of an international order that Canada prospered under for decades.
The Canadian historian Margaret MacMillan has drawn a parallel with 1914, when leaders who did not want war nevertheless felt unable to back down. What worries her most is “the possibility of accident”.
For investors, all this raises an uncomfortable question: what should you do with your money when the world seems increasingly dangerous? Selling and waiting for calmer times can seem sensible.
History offers a different answer. It is less simple than ‘markets always recover’. It is also more useful.
What the Record Shows
Take 1914. When the First World War broke out, the Toronto Stock Exchange closed for three months, for fear of a financial panic. The New York Stock Exchange did not resume trading in shares until December. Nobody then knew how the war would end, or what it would do to their savings.
Wars have done real damage to investors. The UBS Global Investment Returns Yearbook, which tracks markets back to 1900, finds that the two world wars and the oil shock of 1973 to 1974 were behind three of the six worst episodes for large global stock markets.
But the threat of war has not been a reliable guide to what markets do next. The Yearbook compared a measure of geopolitical threat with the stock market returns that followed, and found no relationship. Even in peacetime, economic problems, not geopolitics, set off three of the four largest stock market falls. The fourth, in 1973 to 1974, was set off by geopolitics but played out as an economic crisis.
Over the long run, the record is clear. In the 21 countries with continuous investment records back to 1900, stocks were the best-performing asset class in every one.
That word ‘continuous’ matters. The Yearbook covers 35 markets, and only 21 have continuous records. Some of the others are simply younger. But investors in Russia after 1917, and in China after 1949, lost everything when communist revolutions shut their stock markets. So the lesson is not that every market recovers. It is that nobody can know in advance which ones will, and spreading your money widely means you are not betting on a single market.
Concentration is the Risk You Don’t Notice
The first lesson comes from Canada’s own market. At the peak of the technology boom in 2000, Nortel Networks made up about a third of the TSE 300, then the main index of Canadian stocks. Someone who owned only Canadian stocks, even a wide spread of them, had a large part of their money riding on one company.
Nortel’s shares peaked at $124.50 in July 2000. By November 2002, they were worth $1.94, a fall of more than 98 per cent. The company filed for bankruptcy protection in January 2009.
The bigger problem is that Canada is a small part of the world. It makes up about 3 per cent of the value of global stock markets, as measured by the MSCI ACWI index in October 2026. A portfolio of only Canadian stocks leaves out the other 97 per cent.
Does that matter? The UBS Yearbook looked at 32 markets from 1974 to 2025. Once the effect of currency swings was removed, investors in the vast majority of them got a better return for the risk they took by investing globally rather than only at home.
Concentration is a risk whether it sits in one company or one country.
The Risk You Can Live With
The second lesson is about how much risk you can actually live with. Fear feels much the same, whatever causes it. In the 2008 financial crisis, a nurse from Manitoba had more than 80 per cent of her savings in stocks. MoneySense magazine told her story in 2012.
In December 2008, as markets fell, she asked her advisor to move everything into money market funds. He talked her out of it, saying markets would recover. In February 2009, she insisted on getting out.
When she went back into the market later that year, it was with the same mix as before. She could not stick with it. “I panicked because it was too risky for me,” she told MoneySense. Looking back, she could see where the problem lay. “It wasn’t that I was wrong, it was that my portfolio was wrong.”
Knowing that markets recover is not the same as sitting through a fall. As MoneySense put it, many investors overestimate their ability to deal with losses. The best portfolio is not the one with the highest potential return. It is the one you will still hold when the news is at its worst.
Whether your own mix passes that test is worth checking while markets are calm, not in the middle of a crisis.
What History Can and Can’t Tell You
The Ontario-born economist John Kenneth Galbraith wrote that “there can be few fields of human endeavor in which history counts for so little as in the world of finance.”
Mark Carney may be right that the world is changing. History does not say he is wrong, and it cannot promise that the next crisis will end well. But it does show what has helped investors through dangerous times before: owning a wide spread of the world’s markets, and a mix you can hold when the news is bad.
The hard part is not knowing these lessons. It is following them when you are frightened.
Sources
Bortolotti, D. (2012). Renovate your portfolio. MoneySense.
Carney, M. (2026). Principled and pragmatic: Canada’s path. Address to the World Economic Forum Annual Meeting, Davos, 20 January 2026.
Galbraith, J.K. (1990). A Short History of Financial Euphoria.
Global News (2012). Timeline: Nortel, the rise and fall of a telecom giant.
CPP Investments (2000). CPP Investment Board Reduces Portfolio Exposure to Nortel
Maclean’s (2002). Nortel struggles to recover its worth. The Canadian Encyclopedia.
MSCI (2026). MSCI ACWI Index (CAD) factsheet, 30 October 2026.
RFE/RL (2026). Russia is behaving like a rogue state. Interview with Margaret MacMillan, 3 October 2026.
Somerset Webb, M. (2022). Ukraine crisis: for investors, things may well be different this time. MoneyWeek.
TMX Group. Historical timeline (Toronto Stock Exchange closure, 1914).
UBS (2026). Global Investment Returns Yearbook 2026: summary edition.
While Justwealth provided financial support for this article, the views and opinions expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Justwealth, or its employees. The content of the article is provided solely for information purposes only and should not be construed as advice of any kind.

Comments are closed.